

She meets
sis — 30 years later
By Paula S. Bernstein
for The Brooklyn Paper
I never thought I’d write a memoir. Sure, I endured my fair
share of adolescent angst and struggles with depression, but really, compared
to most memoirists, my life story is pretty humdrum. I didn’t spend
my childhood zigzagging across the country in a station wagon with
my mom (the prostitute) or battle alcoholism at age 12.
Then, three and a half years ago, I got a call from the identical twin
sister I never knew I had. Each of us had been adopted and raised by separate
families — neither of which were informed that their new bouncing
baby girl was part of a matched set.
That was strange enough, but once my twin and I started doing research
about why we had been separated, we found that we had briefly been part
of a twins study on the age-old topic of nature vs. nurture.
Which led, as you might imagine, to the memoir (co-written with my sister,
Elyse Schein).
In it, we investigate the reason for our separation and the emotionally
turbulent process of eventually getting to know each other as adult sisters
who never had a childhood. While our reunion was joyful, it was not always
easy. Apparently, having identical DNA did not guarantee that we would
understand one another.
In writing the book — “Identical Strangers: A Memoir of Twins
Separated and Reunited” (Random House) — I made a concerted
effort to portray myself realistically, warts-and-all. Now I worry that
perhaps I was too realistic. Maybe not everyone — even my longtime
Park Slope neighbors — will find my “character” sympathetic.
They might not understand my initial reluctance to be a twin or my hesitance
to seek out my biological family.
With the memoir about to hit bookstores — and the requisite reading
at the Barnes and Noble on October 24 — I am trying to reconcile
myself to the fact that strangers, acquaintances and friends will know
as much about me and my hang-ups as my therapist. Of course, I want people
to read the book, but I am wary of the attention my newly gained notoriety
will inevitably bring.
Am I prepared for my favorite waitress at Two Boots to ask if I am still
taking anti-depressants or for the helpful saleswoman at Otto to analyze
my relationship with my sister? I dread the thought of neighborhood moms
shaking their heads and clucking behind my back at Tea Lounge after reading
all about my abandonment issues.
In reality, our book is not a juicy tell-all, but rather an exploration
of what it feels like to discover that you’re an identical twin.
Elyse and I grappled with the age-old question: what is it that makes
us who we are?
Funny, but during all these years when I thought my life was too dull
to write about, I had no idea that I would end up co-writing a memoir
with my identical twin.
And now that I know her, I realize I couldn’t have written my own
life’s story without her.
Paula Bernstein is a writer/journalist who lives in Park Slope.
|